If you're struggling to grow a full, healthy beard, one major factor that could be holding you back is moisture. Consistent hair growth is inhibited by brittle, dry, and damaged hair, so your beard needs to be properly moisturized to reach its full potential. This is where beard oils come in – these products help soften and condition hair and skin, promoting healthy growth.
In this article, we'll compare two of the best beard oils on the market – Proraso and Wild Willies, to see which beard oil for men comes out on top.
We will be comparing these two products based on these factors:
-
Ingredients
-
Ease-of-Use
-
Scent
-
Affordability
Table of Contents
Quick Take
Overall Winner: Wild Willies
Wild Willies Beard Oil is our overall winner, as it is designed specifically for beard growth, and it contains a range of potent ingredients that are known to stimulate and promote healthy hair growth. Its ease of use and affordability is also impressive.
Proraso Beard Oil is a close second, as it is formulated to tame, smooth, and nourish facial hair. While it does have natural ingredients and several scent options, it also uses synthetic fragrances and sits at a higher cost than its competitor.
The Most Effective Beard Oils: An Overview
Beard oils are a blend of carrier and essential oils. Carrier oils are "base" oils that make up most of the product, while essential oils are added for their specific benefits.
The carrier oils used in beard oil can vary, but some of the most common include jojoba oil, grapeseed oil, sweet almond oil, and coconut oil. These oils are all incredibly nourishing for hair and skin, and they help to keep the beard looking and feeling its best.
This makes oils ideal for moisturizing and hydrating because beard hairs tend to be coarse and dry. Beards tend to consist of coarse hair, which requires more hydration than the hair on your head or the rest of your body.
The essential oils added to beard oil can also vary, but some of the most common include eucalyptus, tea tree, peppermint, and rosemary oil.
Proraso Beard Oil
Proraso is one of the leading names in male grooming, and its beard oil is a popular choice for many men. This product is formulated to tame, smooth, nourish and protect the hair on your face.
Wild Willies Beard Oil
Wild Willies is another popular brand when it comes to beard care. Their beard oil is designed to stimulate hair follicles for growth and strengthen and prevent beard itch & skin irritation. It is also said to promote shine and elasticity within facial hair.
Beard Oil
$10.00
A Badass Beard Oil that hydrates and softens your beard. The right consistency so your beard feels soft yet not greasy. Experience the ultimate in beard care with Wild Willies Beard Oil, designed for badass beard care enthusiasts. Restores Moisture… Read More
Ingredients
Proraso
The Proraso beard oil uses 97% natural ingredients and is both cruelty-free and vegan. It is free from parabens, phthalates, silicones, mineral oils, artificial colors, and SLS.
-
Omega 3
-
Omega 6
-
Rich walnut oil
-
Sunflower oil
-
Avocado oil
-
Macadamia nut oil
Proraso beard oil provides intense moisture and conditioning with the Omega 3, Omega 6, and walnut and sunflower oils.
Wild Willies
Wild Willies beard oil uses 10 natural vitamins, essential oils, and nourishing ingredients. It’s an all-natural, chemical, preservative, and colorant-free product.
-
Argan oil
-
Cedarwood oil
-
Jojoba oil
Wild Willies beard oil stimulates hair follicles and promotes beard growth with cedarwood and argan oil, and the jojoba oil is great for moisturizing.
By using argan oil, cedarwood oil, and jojoba oil, this product is able to nourish both the hair and skin while also stimulating hair follicles and promoting beard growth.
-
10 natural vitamins, essential oils, and nourishing ingredients
-
All-natural: chemical, preservative, and colorant free
Winner: Draw
Both Proraso and Wild Willies use natural ingredients that are beneficial for both the hair and skin. However, it's important to note that Wild Willies does have a slight edge as it contains more ingredients that are specifically designed to promote healthy growth.
Ease-of-Use
Proraso
This product uses an eye-dropper bottle to apply beard oil. While some customers enjoy choosing the exact number of drops they want to use, this packaging can be messy and waste product if not careful.
Wild Willies
This beard oil comes in a pump-action bottle, which makes it much easier to apply the product evenly to your facial hair. It also helps to prevent waste, as you won't end up using too much product or making a mess.
Winner: Wild Willies
The pump-action bottle used by Wild Willies premium beard oil is much easier to use and helps to prevent waste.
Scent
Proraso
Proraso beard oil is available in a variety of scent options, which is great for those who prefer a certain smell. They also offer full lines with the same scents for a cohesive grooming experience.
-
Refresh - Eucalyptus and Rosemary
-
Cypress and Vetyver
-
Azure Lime - Mint and Citrus
-
Wood and Spice - Cedarwood, Saffron, and Vanilla
However, it's worth noting that they use synthetic fragrances, which some customers may not be pleased with, especially those with sensitive skin.
Wild Willies
Unlike other beard oils, Wild Willies scents are derived from the natural ingredients used in the product. This means that you won't find any synthetic fragrances, which is great for those with sensitive skin or who prefer to live a greener lifestyle.
There are two scent options available:
-
Original: Fresh and Woodsy
-
Cool Mint: Eucalyptus and Peppermint
Winner: Tie
While we love that Wild Willies uses only natural ingredients to scent their product, the fact that there are only two scent options available is a bit limiting. Proraso, on the other hand, offers a variety of scent options for each of its lines, giving customers more choice and cohesiveness. So, Wild Willies wins for high-quality and naturally derived scents, whereas Proraso has more options, but uses fragrances.
Beard Oil
$10.00
A Badass Beard Oil that hydrates and softens your beard. The right consistency so your beard feels soft yet not greasy. Experience the ultimate in beard care with Wild Willies Beard Oil, designed for badass beard care enthusiasts. Restores Moisture… Read More
Affordability
Proraso
The Proraso beard oil comes at a steep $16.00 for a 1 oz bottle.
Wild Willies
The Wild Willies beard oil is more affordable at $9.86 for a 2 oz bottle.
Winner: Wild Willies
The beard oil made by Wild Willies is almost half the price of the Proraso option and contains twice as much product. This makes it the clear choice when it comes to price and affordability, especially for those on a budget.
Which oil is best for beard hair: Proraso or Wild Willies?
This one comes in closely, but the overall winner is really up to you and what you're looking for. Depending on your specific needs and wants from a product, either option could be the right choice. Both have great reviews from customers, coming in at about 4.5-out-of-5 stars, respectively.
-
Over-all Winner: Wild Willies Beard Oil
-
Ingredients winner: Tie
-
Fragrance winner: Tie
-
Ease of use winner: Wild Willies
-
Price Winner: Wild Willies
-
Shipping & Returns Winner: Wild Willies
-
Affordability: Wild Willies
Our choice is Wild Willies because it's a more affordable option and it's easier to use. Plus, it's made with naturally derived ingredients like natural essential oils that are beneficial for both coarse facial hair and the skin underneath.
Beard Oil
$10.00
A Badass Beard Oil that hydrates and softens your beard. The right consistency so your beard feels soft yet not greasy. Experience the ultimate in beard care with Wild Willies Beard Oil, designed for badass beard care enthusiasts. Restores Moisture… Read More
