In this article, we'll compare two of the best beard oil brands– Honest Amish and Wild Willies, to see which beard oil is the superior product.
We will be comparing these two products based on these factors:
-
Ingredients
-
Ease-of-Use
-
Scent
-
Affordability
Table of Contents
Quick Take
Overall Winner: Wild Willies
Wild Willies Beard Oil is a high-quality beard oil that uses effective, natural ingredients. It works great for all beard types and helps to promote new hair growth. Their beard oil uses only clean, natural ingredients so that you are putting only good things on your beard. It's affordable for all and easy to apply, making it an easy choice for many.
Honest Amish Beard Oil comes in right behind Wild Willies. It also uses all natural, clean ingredients that work well for all beard types. It comes in at a slightly higher price point, but is still affordable and priced competitively compared to most brands.
The Most Effective Beard Oils: An Overview
Growing a full, healthy beard can be a difficult task for some men. A big hindering factor could be that your beard and skin aren't properly moisturized. Many times, a top-notch, high-quality beard oil can solve your moisture problems.
Beard oils work by hydrating and nourishing your facial hair and skin and replacing the natural oils that can be lost when cleaning it. A good beard oil will also encourage new healthy hair growth and clear up any dandruff, leaving your beard and skin nice and soft.
Beard oils are essentially a blend of natural carrier and essential oils that work together to nourish and moisturize your beard and skin. Carrier oils are known at the base of the product and essential oils are added in for their specific benefits.
Each beard oil uses different carrier oils, but the most commonly used ones are:
-
Jojoba oil
-
Grapeseed oil
-
Sweet Almond oil
-
Coconut oil
These oils are all well known for their abilities to moisturize and nourish the hair and skin. They are great at keeping your beard healthy and looking its best.
Essential oils are usually added for their specific benefits. Some common essential oils you'll see in beard oils are:
-
Eucalyptus oil
-
Tea Tree oil
-
Peppermint oil
-
Rosemary oil
Each offers different benefits like stimulating hair growth, soothing irritation, or adding a pleasant scent.
Wild Willies Beard Oil
Wild Willies is a premier beard care brand that uses all natural ingredients to create high-quality products. The beard oil is specifically designed to stimulate hair follicles for growth and strengthen and prevent beard itch & skin irritation. It also promotes shine and elasticity within facial hair.
Honest Amish Beard Oil
Honest Amish is a men's beard care brand that is popular for their natural ingredients and its organic beard care products. Their beard oil is a all natural product that all beard and skin types can benefit from.
Ingredients
Wild Willies
Wild Willies beard oil uses a blend of natural vitamins, essential oils, and nourishing ingredients. It's all-natural and free of harsh ingredients, so its always nourishing and moisturizing the skin, and not irritating it. Wild Willies beard also includes ingredients to stimulate hair follicles and promote beard growth while also moisturizing.
-
Argan Oil: moisturizes, nourishes, and rejuvenates skin
-
Cedarwood Oil: helps promote beard growth by regulating oil glands
-
Jojoba Oil: moisturizes skin and protects hair follicles from free radical damage
Honest Amish
The Honest Amish beard oil uses all-natural oils, is free from any harsh chemicals. Its clean ingredients help to soothe and soften the skin and help promote new hair growth on the beard.
-
Argan Oil: moisturizes, nourishes, and rejuvenates skin
-
Cedarwood Oil: helps promote beard growth by regulating oil glands
-
Jojoba Oil: moisturizes skin and protects hair follicles from free radical damage
Winner: Tie
Both Honest Amish and Wild Willies use all natural ingredients that are beneficial for both the hair and the skin. The both are free of harmful chemicals, ingredients, and fragrances. They also contain ingredients that are specifically designed to promote healthy growth.
Ease-of-Use
Wild Willies
This beard oil comes in a pump bottle and is meant to be applied to your beard daily. The pump bottle makes it easy to apply the product evenly throughout your beard. It also helps to prevent waste or a mess, because you avoid using too much product.
Honest Amish
This product uses a dropper applicator to disperse the beard oil, and it is also meant to be used daily. The dropper can be somewhat messy and wasteful when using the beard oil.
Winner: Wild Willies
Wild Willies beard oil uses a pump-action bottle that is super easy to use and helps to prevent waste.
Scent
Wild Willies
Wild Willies scents come from the natural ingredients used in the product. This means no synthetic fragrances, which is what you want in your beard and skincare, especially if you have sensitive skin.
There are two scent options available:
-
Original: Fresh and Woodsy
-
Cool Mint: Eucalyptus and Peppermint
Honest Amish
Honest Amish beard oil is available in two scent options - Classic and Unscented. Both options are scented using only natural ingredients and no artificial fragrances.
-
Classic: Natural, sweet, woodsy scent that matches the scent of their beard balm.
-
Unscented: Only 7 ingredients and the only scent is coming from those natural oils.
Winner: Tie
Both Honest Amish and Wild Willies use all natural ingredients and the scents of their products come from natural essential oils. Neither one of these beard oils uses synthetic fragrances, and they both have the same number of scent options, making this an even playing field.
Affordability
Wild Willies
The Wild Willies beard oil is slightly more affordable at $9.86 for a 2 oz bottle.
Honest Amish
The Honest Amish beard oil comes at a smidge higher price tag of $13.87 for a 2 oz bottle.
Winner: Wild Willies
Wild Willies beard oil is a slightly lower price than the Honest Amish option, at $4.93/ounce vs. $6.93/ounce, respectively. This gives Wild Willies a slight edge when it comes to price and affordability.
Beard Oil
$10.00
A Badass Beard Oil that hydrates and softens your beard. The right consistency so your beard feels soft yet not greasy. Experience the ultimate in beard care with Wild Willies Beard Oil, designed for badass beard care enthusiasts. Restores Moisture… Read More
Which oil is best for beard hair: Honest Amish or Wild Willies?
These two options both receive high remarks from us. But, at the end of the day, our favorite pick is Wild Willies. Both are great choices, but Wild Willies wins out due to ease of use, pricing, and their commitment to sustainability and sourcing all-natural ingredients.
-
Overall Winner: Wild Willies Beard Oil
-
Ingredients winner: Tie
-
Fragrance winner: Tie
-
Ease-of-Use winner: Wild Willies
-
Price Winner: Wild Willies
Beard Oil
$10.00
A Badass Beard Oil that hydrates and softens your beard. The right consistency so your beard feels soft yet not greasy. Experience the ultimate in beard care with Wild Willies Beard Oil, designed for badass beard care enthusiasts. Restores Moisture… Read More
