Billy Jealousy Beard Wash vs. Wild Willies Beard Wash: Find Out Which One is Effective

It's no secret that the key to a great beard is keeping it clean. But with all the different beard washes on the market, how do you know which one is right for you?

In this article, we'll compare Billy Jealousy Beard Wash and Wild Willies Beard Wash to help you make the best decision for your beard.

We’ll cover how each product compared in:

• Ingredients

• Fragrance

• Price

• Efficacy

• Shipping & Returns

Over-all Winner: Wild Willies Beard Wash

Wild Willies: Wild Willies Beard Wash contains natural ingredients that work together to gently cleanse and hydrate your beard. 

Billy Jealousy: Billy Jealousy Beard Wash contains both natural and synthetic ingredients. It works well at cleansing your beard, however, the synthetic ingredients may cause dryness. 

Key Similarities and Differences

Billy Jealousy vs. Wild Willies: Key Ingredients

Beard wash ingredients should include naturally derived oils, vitamins, and minerals that won't strip away the natural oils in your beard. Ingredients like essential oils, Vitamin E, and aloe vera will help condition your beard and keep it soft and manageable.

Billy Jealousy Beard Wash Beneficial Ingredients

Billy Jealousy Beard Wash contains 5 key ingredients that provide the following benefits: cleanses your skin and facial hair, protects your beard from environmental factors, and stimulates hair follicles. 

Billy Jealousy Beard Wash Key Ingredients

• Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice - Hydrates your beard

• Hydrolyzed Soy Protein - Provides shine

• Green Tea Extract - Stimulates hair follicles

• Lecithin - Prevents beard dandruff

• Vitamin E - Protects your skin and beard from environmental factors 

Wild Willies Beard Wash Beneficial Ingredients

Wild Willies Beard Wash consists of 8 key ingredients that provide many benefits including the following: gently cleanses your beard, softens facial hair and skin, removes dead skin cells, and protects your skin from irritation. 

Wild Willies Beard Wash Key Ingredients

• Vitamin E - Softens your skin and beard

• Peppermint Oil - Stimulates beard growth

• Eucalyptus Oil - Prevents irritation

• Lemongrass Oil - Removes dead skin cells

• Aloe Vera - Prevents beard itch and irritation

• Citric Acid - Prevents frizz

• Decyl Glucoside - Provides a natural foaming effect to gently cleanse your facial hair

• Lauryl Betaine - Natural cleansing agent derived from vegetables

Billy Jealousy Potentially Irritating Ingredients

Billy Jealousy Beard Wash is made with a blend of both natural and synthetic ingredients. They claim that they use these harmful ingredients to effectively cleanse your beard, however, using only natural ingredients does an even better job at cleansing your beard without the harmful side effects.

• Methylchloroisothiazolinone - preservative

• Methylisothiazolinone - preservative

• Fragrance - perfuming

The above ingredients can irritate your skin and cause an allergic reaction. According to Decode INCI, the two preservatives are only allowed in rinse-off products since they are known to be harmful to your skin if not rinsed off thoroughly.

Wild Willies Potentially Irritating Ingredients

Wild Willies Beard Wash is made with a blend of essential oils, vitamins, natural cleansers, and Aloe Vera. It does not contain any harsh chemicals like sulfates or parabens that can dry out your hair and skin. 

• Peppermint Oil

• Eucalyptus Oil

Peppermint and Eucalyptus Oil are essential oils that can rarely cause a reaction if you are sensitive to these ingredients, however, they also have many benefits. 

If you don’t know if you are allergic to these ingredients, you can simply test it on a small area of your skin to check if you have a reaction before applying it to your beard. 

Peppermint oil helps cleanse the beard and the skin underneath it while also providing a refreshing scent. It can help soothe irritation and itchiness and also help promote hair growth.

The eucalyptus oil in beard wash can help get rid of any dirt or oil that may be clogging the pores, which can lead to beard itchiness and other skin problems.

Winner: Wild Willies

When it comes to ingredients, Wild Willies takes the cake. Wild Willies Beard Wash contains only natural ingredients that work together to cleanse and soothe your beard, while Billy Jealousy Beard Wash contains preservatives that may cause skin irritation and dryness. 

Fragrance

Wild Willies Beard Wash only has one scent, which comes from essential oils of peppermint and eucalyptus oil. It will leave your beard and skin smelling minty fresh. They also have a ProGro Beard Shampoo made with biotin and caffeine to help stimulate beard growth. 

Billy Jealousy Beard Wash has 3 different scents made with synthetic fragrances, which is a generic term that could consist of 30-50 different chemicals. If you have sensitive skin, then it would be best to avoid beard wash with added fragrances. 

Wild Willies Options

• Original Beard Wash

• ProGro Beard Wash

Billy Jealousy Options

• Original Beard Wash (Woodsy/Lavendar)

• USA Beard Wash (Patchouli/Sandalwood)

• Devil’s Delight Beard Wash (Black Pepper/Sandalwood)

Winner: Wild Willies

Although Billy Jealousy has more fragrance options, Wild Willies is scented using only essential oils that won’t dry out your skin. 

Price

Wild Willies Beard Wash is $3.23 per ounce, which is a great price for the quality that you get. 

Billy Jealousy Beard Wash is only $2.50 per ounce but uses both natural and synthetic ingredients and is not as good of quality as Wild Willes. 

Winner: Draw

Billy Jealousy is cheaper than Wild Willies, however, it doesn’t have as many quality ingredients. 

Efficacy

After researching feedback from over 50 customers, we came up with a list of pros/cons for both Wild Willies and Billy Jealousy Beard Wash. 

Wild Willies:

Wild Willies Beard Wash cleanses your facial hair and the skin underneath while simultaneously hydrating and conditioning your beard. 

The only complaint is that some customers claim the scent is light, however, that could also be a pro if you are sensitive to strong smells. 

Billy Jealousy:

Billy Jealousy Beard Wash works well at cleansing your beard, however, the harsh ingredients can dry out your facial hair and skin. 

The main customer complaint is that after using Billy Jealousy Beard Wash, it left their beard and skin feeling itchy and dry. 

Winner: Wild Willies

In terms of efficacy, Wild Willies is the winner. Wild Willies Beard Wash cleanses and conditions your beard, whereas Billy Jealousy Beard Wash may cause dryness. 

Shipping & Returns

Wild Willies allows free returns within 30 days of purchase and free shipping on orders over $50. They also offer a free VIP email subscription for 10% off all products. 

Billy Jealousy allows returns within 45 days of purchase, however, they do not say if shipping and handling fees are required. They also offer a flat rate shipping fee of $5.95 on all US orders, and free shipping on orders over $59. 

Winner: Wild Willies

When it comes to shipping and returns, Wild Willies and Billy Jealousy are pretty comparable. However, Wild Willies comes out on top. Wild Willies allows free shipping on orders over $50 while Billy Jealousy offers free shipping over $59. It is also unclear if Billy Jealousy requires shipping and handling fees on returns. 

Conclusion: Billy Jealousy vs. Wild Willies 

Overall Winner: Wild Willies Beard Wash

Ingredients winner: Wild Willies

Fragrance winner: Wild Willies

Price Winner: Tie

Efficacy Winner: Wild Willies

Shipping & Returns Winner: Wild Willies

Wild Willies Beard Wash has a cleaner ingredients list, while Billy Jealousy Beard Wash has ingredients that may cause skin irritation and dryness. 

Billy Jealousy offers 3 unique scents, however, they use synthetic fragrances, and Wild Willies uses essential oils. 

Billy Jealousy Beard Wash is more budget-friendly, however, Wild Willies Beard Wash is higher quality. 

Billy Jealousy Beard Wash works well at thoroughly cleansing your beard, however, Wild Willies hydrates and cleanses your beard simultaneously. 

What are your thoughts?

Leave a comment below and let us know if we missed anything or if there are other reviews you would like to see. We would love to hear from you!

Beard Shampoo - with PROGRO

$13.00

  The perfect, all-natural way to keep your beard clean. Packed with organic essential oils to clean and condition all beard types. Stop washing your beard with hair shampoo. Deep clean Nourish & Strengthen  … Read More

Learn More