Baxter vs. Wild Willies: Which Beard Oil Is Better For Your Beard

In this blog post, we’ll compare two popular beard oils: Wild Willies Beard Oil and Baxter Beard Oil, to help you decide which one is right for you.

We’ll cover how each product compares in:

• Key similarities and differences

• Ingredients

• Scents

• Price

Let’s get down to it!

Key Summary: Wild Willies vs Baxter

Wild Willies Oil

Wild Willies are the experts on beard care. They offer oil that has all-natural and high-quality ingredients. There are never any hidden ingredients. Plus, they offer one of the best values on the market.

Baxter of California Beard Oil

The Baxter of California beard oil boasts offering premium products without being pretentious. While they do offer paraben-free products, their beard oil does contain fragrance- which can be harsh on hair and skin. Plus, their products are still rather expensive compared to their competitors. 

The Overall Winner

Wild Willies is the overall winner for offering a great-smelling product without the need for synthetic fragrance or other additives. Plus, you simply can’t beat the great price for a product that works. 

Key Similarities and Differences

Key Similarities:

• Beard use: Beard oil moisturizes and is designed to optimized beard hair health by locking in moisture and nourishing hair follicles (and the skin underneath)- for all beard styles.   

Key Differences:

• Smell: Wild Willies offers two fragrance-free options; Baxter of California offers one scent with fragrance. 

• Ingredients: Wild Willies never has hidden fragrances or additives- only high-quality products that are organic when possible. 

• Price: Wild Willies offers a very competitive price of less than $5 per ounce of beard oil.

• Product source: Wild Willies is proudly made in the US, while Baxter of California does not disclose.  

Baxter of California Beard Oil vs. Wild Willies: Key Ingredients

Baxter Beard Oil Beneficial Ingredients

Baxter of California beard oil consists of 6 key ingredients that provide various benefits for promoting healthy hair growth, including the following: 

• Apricot Kernel Oil: this quick absorbing beard oil moisturizes for soothing, preventing, and managing acne, inflammation, and beard dryness

• Avocado Oil: avocado oil nourishes the facial hair and skin to give it a natural glow

• Squalene: a fibrous ingredient that gives the beard a natural shine, reduces frizz and reduces brittle hair

• Olive Fruit Oil: for moistruzing, softening, and protecting (not only your hair but your skin too) 

• Vitamin E: an antioxidant to reduce inflammation and signs of aging (such as wrinkles and scars)

• Soybean Oil: moisturizes and gives your hair a glossy shine

• Fragrance: an undisclosed chemically derived scent that can be harsh and dry both skin and hair 

Wild Willies Beard Oil Beneficial Ingredients

Wild Willies Beard Oil consists of 9 ingredients that provide many benefits for promoting healthy hair growth, including the following: 

• Apricot Kernel Oil: reduces inflammation by soothing the skin and hair follicles

• Grapeseed Oil: a moisturizing oil that is rich in vitamin E for soothing and helping to manage the appearance of scars, wrinkles and acne

• Argan Oil: prevent splits ends and manages frizz to allow healthy facial growth

• Castor Oil: hydrates the facial hair and gives your beard a nice voluminous shine

• Gold Jojoba Oil: for not only your hair, this oil moisturizes the skin underneath to tackle an itchy beard, dandruff, and other common beard irritations

• Vitamin E (Non-GMO): an antioxidant to help with inflammation, signs of aging, and nourishing brittle hair

• Cedarwood Oil: stimulates circulation to boost beard hair growth potential

• Tea Tree Oil: perfect for soothing sensitive skin, keeping the beard clean, and supporting facial hair growth

• Rosemary Oil: another circulation booster that also has anti-inflammatory properties to nourish your beard and support growth

Note: The blend of essential oils is slightly different with their Cool Mint scent, trading rosemary for soothing and refreshing eucalyptus and mint. 

The Winner for Ingredients

Wild Willies is the clear winner here. Both Baxter of California and Wild Willies contain naturally derived ingredients like carrier oils and Vitamin E. However, Wild Willies’ contains only natural ingredients, while Baxter of California Beard Oil contains added fragrances that could cause skin irritation. 

Scents

Wild Willies Beard Oil Scents

Wild Willies Beard Oil gets its fragrance from essential oils and currently has 2 different scents to choose from. 

• Original: A blend of cedarwood, tea tree, and rosemary gives this oil a subtle earthy and woodsy scent. 

• Cool mint: A refreshing blend of eucalyptus and mint for a minty fresh scent.

They also have two great hemp beard oils available, known to further boost beard growth potential, in Fresh Squeeze and Wild Vanilla Spice. 

Baxter Beard Oil Scents

Baxter of California Beard Oil gets its fragrance from artificial fragrances. The term fragrance on an ingredient list is a “generic term that can be made of up 30 to 50 different chemicals”, many of which are harmful and can cause skin irritation. 

Currently, Baxter of California Beard Oil is only available in one scent that is described as being woodsy.

The Winner for Scent

When it comes to scents, Wild Willies is the winner. Wild Willies offers 2 different natural derived fragrances, while Baxter of California only offers 1 artificial fragrance. 

Price

Wild Willies

Wild Willies Beard Oil is for sale for $9.86 for a 2-ounce bottle. This makes it less than 2 ounces per ounce. Even if you splurge on their Hemp Oils specifically designed for bear growth, it is still under $20 for a 1 ounce bottle. 

Plus, Wild Willies offer free shipping on orders over $50 and a 10% for subscriptions. 

Beard Oil

$10.00

A Badass Beard Oil that hydrates and softens your beard. The right consistency so your beard feels soft yet not greasy. Experience the ultimate in beard care with Wild Willies Beard Oil, designed for badass beard care enthusiasts. Restores Moisture… Read More

Original - $10.00 Cool Mint - $10.00 Bourbon Cedar - $10.00

Learn More

Baxter

Baxter of California Beard Oil is $28 per ounce, making it almost 6 times more than Wild Willies. 

Plus, Baxter of California also offers a subscription incentive and free shipping on orders more than $50. 

The Winner for Price

In terms of pricing, Wild Willies oil comes out on top when compared to Baxter of California beard grooming oil. Wild Willies Beard Oil is a great budget-friendly option without compromising on quality. 

Conclusion: Baxter of California vs. Wild Willies

We’ve tallied up each category and Wild Willes wins by a landslide when compared to Baxter of California beard grooming oil. Let’s review:

Overall Winner: Wild Willies Beard Oil

Ingredients Winner: Wild Willies for high-quality ingredients that promote healthy hair growth (nothing hidden). 

Scents Winner: Wild Willies for all-natural scents that aren’t harsh on the skin. 

Price Winner: Wild Willies for the best prices around. 

Overall, it pays to choose a brand that specialized in beard care. They guarantee to provide you with the best quality products on the market. It's a win for not only your hair but your skin too. If you’re looking for beard oil, we highly recommend trying Wild Willies beard oils.