Whether you have a full-blown lumberjack beard or just a light dusting of scruff, you want to make sure that it looks shiny and healthy. This can be a challenge, especially if you live in a cold or dry climate.
One way to combat dry facial hair or skin is by using beard oil. But with so many different brands and types of on the market, how do you know which one is right for you?
In this article, we will compare two popular brands of beard oil: Art of Shaving and Wild Willies.
In this article, we’ll cover
-
Key similarities and differences
-
Ingredients
-
Scents
-
Value
Table of Contents
Art of Shaving vs Wild Willies Beard Oil: A Quick Review
Art of Shaving Beard Oil
Art of Shaving Beard Oil is a lightweight, non-greasy oil that nourishes your facial hair and skin. It is made with a blend of botanical oils, including avocado, jojoba, and evening primrose. While they boast 99% plant-based products, they do not have their label available. In fact, their website mentions always checking product labels to ensure compatibility once you have already purchased it.
Wild Willies Beard Oil
The Wild Willies oil blend is also lightweight and non-greasy, but it contains a different blend of oils- including argan, grapeseed, and apricot seed oil. Wild Willies offers full ingredient transparency and is dedicated to using only the best ingredients possible. Plus, all their products are proudly made in the US.
The Overall Winner
Wild Willies is the clear winner in this matchup against the Art of Shaving. Not only are their products made with higher quality ingredients, but you'll know exactly what you're getting before you hit that purchase button. Plus, the great value is just the icing on top.
Key Similarities and Differences
|
Wild Willies Beard Oil |
Art of Shaving Beard Oil |
|
|
Key Similarities:
-
5-star reviews: Both have happy customers and high-quality customer care.
-
Beard use: Both oils contain lightweight oils and essential oils designed to be a leave-in beard conditioner for a moisturized beard and healthy shine. Just use your fingers to rub the products into your skin and beard.
Key Differences:
-
Where products are sourced from: Wild Willies products are sourced from the U.S.; whereas Art of Shaving does not disclose this information
-
Scent choices: Wild Willies offers naturally scented options, while it is unclear whether there's fragrance in Art of Shaving products.
-
Price: Wild Willies offers the best value for your money- hands down, with free shipping and subscription services to boot on all their grooming products.
-
Label transparency: Art of Shaving does not share its ingredient label or give additional information until after you've made a purchase.
Beard Oil Ingredients
Art of Shaving Beard Oil Ingredients
Let’s review the key ingredients in this blend for a well-conditioned beard:
-
Avocado Oil: Used as a carrier oil because it is packed with nutrients that are good for your beard hair and skin for a healthy shine and appearance.
-
Jojoba Oil: A carrier oil that closely resembles the natural oils produced by your skin, so it is quickly absorbed to soften the skin and beard hair follicles.
-
Evening primrose Oil: Known for helping with dryness, wrinkles, and skin irritation.
*Other ingredients that may be in this formula are not included due to a lack of label details.
Try pairing your oils with these other products:
The Art of Shaving recommends using other products from their shop. Use their shaving oil, stubble balm, beard wash (to first remove dirt), and beard brush for the best beard grooming results.
Wild Willies Beard Oil
These lightweight oils are a great beard conditioner for a healthy shine. Let’s review key Ingredients:
-
Apricot Kernel Oil: High in oleic acid and Vitamin A to help soothe dry skin and condition your beard hair.
-
Grapeseed Oil: A light oil that is quickly absorbed by the skin for moisturizing and helps to reduce inflammation.
-
Argan Oil: A conditioning oil that is rich in Vitamin E and essential fatty acids to help hydrate the skin.
-
Castor Oil: A thicker oil that is known to help promote beard hair growth.
-
Gold Jojoba Oils: A carrier oil that closely resembles the natural oils produced by your skin and is quickly absorbed.
-
Vitamin E: A natural preservative and antioxidant that is good for the skin and beard hair to enhance a natural glow.
-
Cedarwood Oil: A natural essential oil with a woodsy scent.
-
Tea Tree Oil: A natural essential oil with a fresh scent that has antifungal and antibacterial properties, especially great for sensitive skin.
-
Rosemary Oil: A natural essential oil with a fresh, herbaceous scent that is known to help stimulate hair growth.
Note: These are the key ingredients for the Original blend. The Cool Mint Blend is a slightly different high-quality blend of essential oils. It also includes spearmint oil for a refreshing scent and soothing feel to the skin.
Try pairing your oil with these other great beard products:
Maximize your beard grooming efforts with other high-quality beard products, such as beard wash. Plus, you can try a variety of beard balms and oil elixirs infused with ingredients like hemp, caffeine, and biotin to maximize your beard growth potential.
Beard Oil Scents
Art of Shaving Scents
-
Black Pepper & Cedar: A balanced warm and spicy blend of pepper and sandalwood.
-
Citrus Mint Basil: A lightweight, crisp, and refreshing smell.
Wild Willies Scents
-
Original: A subtle herby, woodsy, and masculine smell from the natural blend of oils (rosemary, cedarwood, and tea tree)
-
Cool mint: A refreshing and cooling blend of minty oils.
The Winner for Best Smells
Without a label, it's assumed that there are probably synthetic fragrances included in the Art of Shaving products. Thus, Wild Willies is the best option for getting great-smelling natural products with no harsh additives.
Beard Oil
$10.00
A Badass Beard Oil that hydrates and softens your beard. The right consistency so your beard feels soft yet not greasy. Experience the ultimate in beard care with Wild Willies Beard Oil, designed for badass beard care enthusiasts. Restores Moisture… Read More
Beard Oil Value
Art of Shaving
The Art of Shaving oils are available for $34 in a 1-ounce bottle. Plus, you can get 15% off your first order. They do not offer any free shipping .Instead, you can choose your method of delivery based on how quickly you’d like it to ship.
Wild Willies
The Wild Willies oils are for sale for $9.86 in a 2-ounce spray bottle. Plus, get 10% off when you sign up for a subscription account at checkout (just input your details on the payment page). You can also expect free shipping on orders over $50 from the shop and a guarantee for a quick delivery.
The Winner for Best Value
The Wild Willies beard oils are the better value. You get twice as much product for almost a third of the price. In addition, tap into more savings with a subscription.
Wait, does beard oil need to be expensive to be effective?
Definitely not. A good quality beard oil is made with natural ingredients and does not need to be expensive to work well. High prices on products tend to indicate a bigger marketing budget and branding strategies, not better quality products.
Art of Shaving or Wild Willies: Which should you choose?
Wild Willies is the clear winner against the Art of Shaving beard products. It not only has great scents, but it also contains natural ingredients that are beneficial for your skin and facial hair.
Let's review how these beard oils compared one more time:
-
Ingredients: Wild Willies for an all-natural formula that works.
-
Scent: Wild Willies offers naturally scented oils that leave your beard hair smelling great.
-
Price: When compared to other brands, Wild Willies value just can't be beat, especially when considering the quality.
If you’re looking for an affordable beard oil that will make your facial hair look shiny and healthy, we highly recommend trying Wild Willies Beard Oil.
Beard Oil
$10.00
A Badass Beard Oil that hydrates and softens your beard. The right consistency so your beard feels soft yet not greasy. Experience the ultimate in beard care with Wild Willies Beard Oil, designed for badass beard care enthusiasts. Restores Moisture… Read More
